December 10, 2023

Halloween Hayride (40423) Review

The LEGO® Group often releases seasonal sets to coincide with major holidays. Most years, we get Halloween kit. This year is no exception with Halloween Hayride (40423). While it is a small set, it contains a few fun details.

NOTE: The LEGO® Group provided this set for review. However, the provision of products does not guarantee a favorable review. I will use my usual rating system (click here to learn more) and provide my honest opinion.


  • NAME: Halloween Hayride
  • SET #: 40423
  • THEME: Iconic/Seasonal
  • COST: $16.99 CAD
  • BRICK COUNT: 148
  • MINIFIGURES: 2 + 1 Skeleton
  • RELEASE DATE: August 1, 2020
Halloween Hayride (40423) box contents.


  • VALUE: 84% (Good value in terms of cost-per-brick and build time.)
  • BUILD: 80% (Aesthetically pleasing, but no new techniques and entrance arch is not sturdy.)
  • MINIFIGURES: 91% (Good characters and accessories, excellent brick-to-fig ratio.)
  • ENTERTAINMENT: 85% (Fun seasonal set, but not much use for it after October 31.)


VALUE: 84%

Halloween Hayride costs $16.99 in Canada. Additionally, the set contains 148 pieces. Consequently, the cost-per-brick is $0.115. That is good in my books. My average cost-per-brick currently sits at $0.14. I rate the value-per-brick at 87% in this case.

Halloween Hayride (40423) tractor.

Halloween Hayride is a short build. It took me 21 minutes. Therefore, at full price you are looking at $0.81 per minute of build time. Again, that is good. Comparatively, my average cost-per-minute is currently $0.83. So, you are right around the average in this case. I rate that at 81%. Averaging this score with the value-per-brick rating gives an overall value grade of 84%.

BUILD: 80%

This set includes a Halloween themed entrance arch, a tractor, and a trailer. None of the builds are particularly complicated, and seasoned builders will not learn any new techniques. However, the product is a fun seasonal display piece. I like the details; you can see that designers put thought into this. I particularly like the use of 1×2 modified bricks with grilles in yellow as hay bales. My only complaint is that the entrance arch is not sturdy. It needs a transverse plate on the bottom. I rate this build at 8/10 (80%).

Halloween Hayride (40423) entrance arch.


Halloween Hayride comes with two Minifigures and a skeleton. Sadly, one of the Minifigures is a stumpy child with unbending legs. However, both characters have front and back printed torsos with nice detailing. Additionally, one has a double-sided face. Neither character has leg printing though. The mummy costume would be better with that additional detail. The set also comes with a jack-o-lantern, bat, skeleton, spider, and two blank orange Minifigure heads to serve as pumpkins. I rate the design of these characters at 25/30 (83%).

Counting the skeleton as a figurine, you get three characters in this set. With 148 pieces, the brick-to-fig ratio is 49-to-1. For a kit this size, that is excellent. Comparatively, my average ratio is currently 150:1. In this case, I rate the ratio score at 99%. Averaging the ratio and design scores gives an overall Minifigure rating of 91%.

Halloween Hayride (40423) minifigure.


This is a fun set with great seasonal display potential. Additionally, it has play value as a kit for kids. It is not the most exciting set, but it offers a fun scene. As an AFOL with Halloween on the horizon, I will keep this built for the season. The Minifigure parts will also find use in my custom projects. Additionally, I am happy to get another jack-o-lantern. However, once Halloween passes, I will recycle this set for parts. As such, I rate the entertainment derived from this set at 8.5/10 (85%)


I like Halloween Hayride (40423). In terms of seasonal sets, you get fun characters and accessories at a good value. However, I do wish the Minifigures had more printing and were both adult characters. With that said, this is an inexpensive Halloween display piece. Additionally, it provides a decent brick selection after recycling on November 1. Halloween Hayride is not my favorite set, but it is a good one for the price. What are your thoughts? Reach out in the comments below or on social media.

Until next time,


Want to support True North Bricks?

If you like the content at True North Bricks, please follow on InstagramFacebookPinterest, or Twitter for regular updates. Additionally, you can support True North Bricks by making your LEGO® (and other) purchases using the links in the menu to the right. These affiliate links earn me a little commission at no extra cost to you, thus helping to manage the cost of running this blog. Thanks for your support!